Opinion

California Lawmakers Grapple With Home Insurance Crisis as End of Session Nears

Published

4 weeks ago

September 6, 2023

The prime topic for 11th hour legislating this year is California's growing home insurance crisis, says Dan Walters. (Shutterstock)

Share with friends

The California Legislature reconvened Tuesday for the final fortnight of its 2023 session with lawmakers facing nearly 1,000 pending measures ranging from consequential to toothlessly symbolic – and perhaps some still to be drafted.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Historically, the last few days of any session are rife with rumors about phantom bills that might surface and be hustled through the process. This year’s prime topic for 11^th hour legislating is the growing home insurance crisis.

Several major insurers have pulled out of the California market, or reduced their exposure, citing unacceptable risks due to massive wildfires and escalating construction costs. Legislators and other state officials, particularly Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara, are feeling pressure both from homeowners who are having their policies cancelled and real estate brokers because mortgages need insurance.

The insurance industry has indicated that shoring up the California market would require legislation or new rules from Lara to allow insurers to build potential future exposure into their premiums, rather than be forced to rely on past experience that may be out of date.

However, such a change would probably increase premiums and consumer activists such as Harvey Rosenfield, founder of Consumer Watchdog and author of the 1988 ballot measure that established the current insurance regulatory apparatus, are denouncing any such changes as a giveaway to the industry.

It’s doubtful that legislation seriously affecting such a complex and touchy subject could be drafted and passed in the few remaining days but no matter what happens — even if it’s nothing — the political fallout could be powerful.

Notwithstanding the buzz about insurance, there are some contentious, high-profile measures that are already on the legislative agenda for the final days, having been cleared for floor action.

Other High-Profile Bills

One survivor is a measure that would elevate child trafficking into a serious crime, which wouldn’t seems to be controversial but became a symbol of the sharp partisan differences over crime and punishment. Democrats stalled the Republican-authored bill in committee but media coverage and pressure from Newsom sprung it from political jail, so to speak.

There’s more bipartisan support for a package of bills to confront California’s deadly epidemic of fentanyl misuse.

Labor unions are making a full-court press in this year’s session with multiple bills to make it easier to organize workers and/or expand mandatory employment benefits, such as more paid sick leave days and a sharp hike in minimum wages for health care workers.

Finally, there are two efforts, backed by Democratic leaders, that would change how measures placed on the statewide ballot by petition are framed. Both are clearly aimed at making ballot processes more difficult, thus thwarting recent efforts by business interests to block new regulations and taxes.

They are specifically aimed at three measures already qualified for the 2024 ballot, one challenging new regulation of the fast food industry, another opposing new restrictions on where oil wells are drilled and a third that would make it much more difficult to raise state and local taxes.

One pending bill, Assembly Bill 121, would change how referenda are worded for voters, and would, if passed, affect both the fast food and oil well referenda. AB 121 also contains an unusual passage to tightly restrict judicial challenges to the law.

The second, Assembly Constitutional Amendment 13, would require that the 2024 measure to require two-thirds votes for local taxes and voter approval of new state taxes would itself need a two-thirds vote to be adopted. Sponsors want to place ACA 13 on the March primary ballot so that it would apply to — and perhaps kill — the November tax restriction measure.

Such are the games of September.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

GV Wire – Explore. Explain. Expose

California Lawmakers Grapple With Home Insurance Crisis as End of Session Nears

About the Author

You may like

Who Is Arthur Engoron? Judge Weighing Future of Donald Trump Empire Is Ivy League-Educated Ex-Cabbie

Armenia Grapples With Multiple Challenges After the Fall of Nagorno-Karabakh

Newsom Names Former Kamala Harris Adviser to Feinstein Senate Seat

Lawmakers Resolve California Fast Food Battle but Clash Still Rages in Another Industry

McCarthy’s Speakership Threatened by Fellow Republican After Vote Averting Government Shutdown

At California GOP Event, Scott and DeSantis Make Their Presidential Case in Trump’s Shadow

Technology and Labor Trade-Offs Create Dilemma for California’s Economy

It’s Only ‘Yokuts Valley’ on Maps? The Confusing Fight Over a Fresno County Town Isn’t Over

Need a COVID-19 Vaccine or at-Home Test? What You Need to Know in Fresno County

Judge Gives Bredefeld, Chavez Win in County Campaign Fund Lawsuit

Clovis Unified Superintendent Discusses Expansion at State of the District

What a Deal: Downtown Fresno Hosts Thrift and Vintage Expo

Dianne Feinstein Always Did Things Her Way in Long Political Career

Technology and Labor Trade-Offs Create Dilemma for California’s Economy

California’s Politicians Point Fingers as Public Tolerance of Homelessness Wears Thin

Lawmakers Resolve California Fast Food Battle but Clash Still Rages in Another Industry

Has California’s Much-Dreaded ‘Job Killer’ List Lost Some of Its Bite?

Newsom Decision on Big Gun and Ammo Tax Hike May Rest With ‘Canoe Theory’

Newsom Burnishes His National Image by Waging New Attack on Oil Industry

California Legislators Whiff on ‘Spiraling Crisis’ in Home Insurance Market

California Unions Scored Big in Legislature This Year, Though They Represent Few

Compromise Settles Dispute Over Status of Franchises in Fast Food Industry

Water Rights Reformers Scored Only a Minor Victory in the Legislature

California Keeps Its Title as Having the Nation’s Highest Poverty Rate

Clovis Unified Superintendent Discusses Expansion at State of the District

The Huge Battle Against Food Deserts in Fresno

GV Wire’s Nancy Price Answers Kim Stephens’ Questions About Controversial PBS Story

LA Purse Snatcher Drags Woman, 75, Across Asphalt Before Fleeing

DeSantis Stops in Fresno for Private Presidential Fundraiser

Teamwork, Hard Work is Key to Clovis Unified’s Continued Success, Folmer Says at Annual Fundraiser

New Police, Fire Tax? Council Wants One More Week to Decide How to Pay for Fresno Growth

These Four Groups Control the California Legislature: Dan Walters

Trump Leads Biden by 9 Points in Latest ABC/Washington Post Poll

This World Renowned Art Icon Crafts His Masterpieces in Fresno

News Minute: Regulators Delay Solar Ruling; Unleashing California’s Economy; Amazon’s Local Hiring Spree

New 24/7 Fresno Gym Was Made For Those Who Don’t Stop