Opinion

Water Rights Reformers Scored Only a Minor Victory in the Legislature

Published

6 days ago

September 16, 2023

Water rights defenders say the state would not have to curtail their supplies if it did a better job of capturing and storing water. (GV Wire File)

Share with friends

A centerpiece of California’s perpetual political and legal wrangling over allocation of water is the complex array of rights that stretch back to the earliest years of statehood in the 19^th century.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Simply put, those who claimed water before 1914, when the state assumed legal control, have “senior rights” that traditionally have entitled them to virtually unlimited supplies even when other users face cutbacks during drought.

The state Water Resources Control Board has made occasional efforts to curtail diversions by senior rights holders when supplies are tight but its legal right to do so is unclear with water rights in conflict with other laws declaring the larger public’s interest in overseeing “beneficial” water use.

One test of the issue resulted in a state appellate court’s 2022 declaration that the state lacked direct authority to block diversions by senior rights holders and suggested that only the Legislature could provide such power.

Although last winter’s heavy rains eased the competition for water that had become intense during several years of severe drought, advocates for overhauling water rights law to give the state more power to protect fish and other wildlife dependent on river flows mounted a major effort in the Legislature this year with three bills.

Together, they would have implemented key recommendations of a study commissioned by the water board that argued for giving it new powers to curtail supplies to water rights holders when warranted.

“When there is not enough water to satisfy all demands, water must be allocated among competing human and environmental uses,” the study declared. “California’s State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) needs to be able to routinely require diverters to curtail (stop) unlawful water uses in order to protect water rights, human health and safety, and the environment from serious harm.”

Water rights holders, most of whom are agricultural water agencies, saw the report and the three bills — accurately — as a frontal assault on their privileged position in the competition for water and mounted a stout defense. If enacted, they argued, the changes would make it infinitely more difficult for farmers to plan crop cycles.

The most far-reaching of the three measures, Assembly Bill 1337, would have overturned the 2022 water rights case and authorized the water board “to issue a curtailment order for any diversion, regardless of basis of right, when water is not available,” but it stalled after winning Assembly approval.

A second, Assembly Bill 460, which would have given the board authority to intervene in water diversions on an emergency basis, suffered the same fate.

Decades-Long Struggle Will Continue

However, the least onerous of the three, from the standpoint of water rights holders, Senate Bill 389, has made it to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s desk. It would give the board more explicit authority to investigate whether water diversions are lawful — within the scope of diverters’ legal rights — and punish violators as trespassers.

It’s certainly less than what water rights reformers want, which means the decades-long struggle over the issue will continue, particularly if the state once again experiences the kind of drought that last winter’s heavy rain and snow storms alleviated. State water officials believe that such droughts will become more common with climate change, or at least will change the mix of precipitation, with less snow and more rain.

However, water rights are just one front — albeit a very important one — in the state’s perpetual conflict over how the precious liquid should be allocated. Water rights defenders say the state would not have to curtail their supplies if it did a better job of capturing and storing water when it’s available, and there’s some validity in that criticism.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

GV Wire – Explore. Explain. Expose

Water Rights Reformers Scored Only a Minor Victory in the Legislature

About the Author

You may like

US Applications for Jobless Benefits Fall to Lowest Level in Nearly 8 Months

The Average Long-Term US Mortgage Rate Edged Up to 7.19% This Week, Slightly Below Its 2023 High

Zelenskyy Delivers Upbeat Message to US Lawmakers on War Progress as Some Republican Support Softens

California’s Anti-Caste Bill Faces Opposition from Hindu Nationalist Groups

Assemblyman Slams CCW Bill: ‘Don’t Lecture Me About Gun Control and Gun Violence’

‘River’ is a Fun-Loving Girl Whose Green Eyes Will Melt Your Heart

Rupert Murdoch, Creator of Fox News, Stepping Down as Head of News Corp. And Fox Corp.

No Labels Push in Closely Divided Arizona Fuels Democratic Anxiety About a Biden Spoiler

Privately-Built High-Speed Train Linking Florida Cities to Debut Friday. California Could Be Next

Iran’s Parliament Passes Stricter Mandatory Headscarf Law Days After Protest Anniversary

Newsom Burnishes His National Image by Waging New Attack on Oil Industry

Biden Administration Announces $600M to Produce COVID Tests and Will Reopen Website to Order Them

Newsom Burnishes His National Image by Waging New Attack on Oil Industry

California Unions Scored Big in Legislature This Year, Though They Represent Few

Compromise Settles Dispute Over Status of Franchises in Fast Food Industry

Water Rights Reformers Scored Only a Minor Victory in the Legislature

California Keeps Its Title as Having the Nation’s Highest Poverty Rate

Newsom May Come to Regret His Pledges to Black Californians

California Housing Policy Takes Two Steps Forward and One Back

California’s Mighty Shipping Industry Threatened by Latest Climate Regulations

California Lawmakers Grapple With Home Insurance Crisis as End of Session Nears

California’s ‘Woke’ Math Curriculum Threatens to Worsen Student Proficiency

Bay Area ‘Doom-Loop’ Is Upending Longtime Political, Economic Dominance of California

California Says Domestic Violence is ‘Nonviolent’ but Link to Mass Shootings Shows Otherwise

Assemblyman Slams CCW Bill: ‘Don’t Lecture Me About Gun Control and Gun Violence’

Four Fixes That Will Unleash Economic Vitality Across California

Tulare County Sheriff Blasts Sacramento CCW Clampdown, Says ‘Open Borders’ Drive Gun Violence

BBC Video: The Struggle for Women’s Rights in Iran After the Death of Masha Amini

Valley Residents: Strong Voices Needed to Crumble the Totalitarian Iranian Regime

News Minute: Concealed Weapon Permits, Granite Park Bailout, Possible Teachers Strike

AG Bonta Says California’s Strict Gun Control Keeps People Safer

GV Wire’s David Taub Answers Kim Stephens’ Questions About Secret $414K Granite Park Bailout

City Hall Covertly Pays $414,000 to Bail Out Granite Park Over Late Utility Bills

‘What I Saw Was a War Zone … and the Best in Humanity’: Clovis 9-11 Ceremonies

Fresno Trustee Susan Wittrup Discusses Keys to Improving Student Literacy

How Fresno PD Caught Teen Suspect in Roosevelt Hit-and Run