Opinion

Technology and Labor Trade-Offs Create Dilemma for California’s Economy

Published

2 months ago

October 1, 2023

Several high priority bills for California's unions this year aimed to at block technology and other labor-saving moves, says Dan Walters. (Shutterstock)

Share with friends

When Hollywood writers initially went on strike against film and television studios, it was for traditional reasons such as pay and working conditions.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Ultimately, however, the stickiest issue was how much, if anything, the studios could employ artificial intelligence to produce scripts, thereby reducing input from human beings and the need for their talents.

It was an important skirmish in a larger conflict over whether technology and corporate consolidation make the economy more productive and globally competitive, or create multitudes of unemployable workers.

Resisting technology and other labor-saving corporate moves to preserve jobs has become, as the writers’ strike demonstrated, a major goal for labor unions, both in contract bargaining and the political arena. And California, not surprisingly, is on the front lines.

Last year, for instance, Gov. Gavin Newsom and the Legislature agreed to spend more money on improving efficiency at the state’s ports, hoping to improve their competitive position vis-à-vis other ports. But at the behest of longshore unions, the legislation specifically banned spending on “fully automated cargo handling equipment.”

One of the California Labor Federation’s highest priority bills in the just-concluded 2023 legislative session was Assembly Bill 316, aimed at banning the use of autonomous, driverless trucks until 2030. But Newsom quickly vetoed it, despite his close connections with unions.

“Autonomous vehicle technology is evolving and DMV remains committed to keeping our rules up to date to reflect its continued development in California,” Newsom said in his veto message.

High Priority Labor Bills Block Technology Improvements

AB 316 was not an outlier. Several other high priority bills for labor were aimed at blocking technology, consolidation and other labor-saving moves by employers.

Assembly Bill 647 would make it more difficult to cut workers when grocery chains merge, while Assembly Bill 627 would make seniority the major criteria in rehiring workers after layoffs.

Other measures, meanwhile, bolstered employment by providing workers with new benefits or wage increases.

Legislation to create a new state agency to oversee wages and working conditions in the fast food industry, passed last year, was challenged by an industry-sponsored referendum that was qualified for the 2024 ballot. That led to a compromise that set a $20 per hour minimum wage for fast food workers.

There was a similar dustup over legislation that would set a $25 per hour minimum wage for health care workers, leading to another compromise.

Still another measure, Senate Bill 616, expands mandatory sick leave from a minimum of three working days to five days.

The overall thrust of these legislative moves has been to make it more difficult for employers to make labor-saving changes while raising their costs for using human labor.

One can certainly understand, and sympathize with, efforts to preserve jobs and increase compensation. But at what point do they backfire, making the state less competitive and indirectly eliminating jobs?

It’s a complicated question but a simplistic example of the dilemma facing the fast food industry, for example, which has been the subject of much political angst this year.

If fast food outlets must pay their workers more and provide them with more sick leave days, does it encourage them to cut staffs even further and rely more on technology, such as the kiosks that McDonald’s uses for food orders?

When the state banned automation investments as it appropriated more money for port modernization last year, John McLaurin, president of the Pacific Merchant Shipping Association, told Newsom in a letter: “California’s ports have no more room to grow – except up. If we are to meet the needs of California consumers and exporters, support hundreds of thousands of supply chain related jobs and function as a competitive gateway, innovation along the waterfront should be encouraged – not stifled.”

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.

GV Wire – Explore. Explain. Expose

Technology and Labor Trade-Offs Create Dilemma for California’s Economy

About the Author

You may like

New Schools, Homes, and a Costco for North Visalia Master-Planned Neighborhood

Oakland Is Getting a New Minor League Team — The Oakland B’s

Oakland City Council Calls for Permanent Cease-Fire in Israel-Hamas War

Bulldog Volleyball Team Takes MWC Title, Faces Stanford in NCAA Tournament

Koch Network Endorses Nikki Haley in Republican Presidential Primary

Cities Crack down on Homeless Encampments. Advocates Say That’s Not the Answer

American Consumers More Confident in November as Holiday Shopping Season Kicks into High Gear

The US Tells Israel Any Ground Campaign in Southern Gaza Must Limit Further Civilian Displacement

Israel and Hamas Agree to Extend Truce for Two More Days, and to Free More Hostages and Prisoners

Hunter Biden Offers to Testify Publicly Before Congress, Setting up a Potential High-Stakes Face-Off

California’s Utilities Commission, Other Consumer Watchdogs, Often Protect Big Companies

As DeSantis and Newsom Go Mano a Mano, Healthcare Is Front and Center

Zakaria: Another Casualty of War: Free Speech on Campus

Ian Bremmer: Is an Israel-Palestine Two-State Solution Possible?

Ian Bremmer: What’s Iran’s Next Move?

PG&E Hits Residents with Electricity Prices Over Double the National Average

California’s Utilities Commission, Other Consumer Watchdogs, Often Protect Big Companies

Closed-off Interstate 10 Is No Stranger to Major Damage or Political Attention

California Keeps Expanding School Curricula. What About Improving Key Subjects?

California Will Finally See a Highly Competitive Contest for U.S. Senate

Political and Economic Stakes Are High for San Francisco This Week

What Went Wrong at EDD? An Investigation of Its Managerial Meltdown

Will Gavin Newsom Wind up as One of California’s Unpopular Ex-Governors?

More Americans Are Expected to ‘Buy Now, Pay Later’ for the Holidays. Analysts See a Growing Risk

Bulldog Volleyball Team Takes MWC Title, Faces Stanford in NCAA Tournament

Operation Christmas Presence Kicks Off Effort to Keep Shoppers Safe This Holiday Season

GV Wire Asks: ‘What Are You Thankful For?’

Wired Wednesday: Is California Putting Nonprofit Mental Health Providers at Risk?

Take a Look Inside the Sparkling New Clovis Senior Center

Tower Restaurant Fire Was Like What You’d See ‘in a Movie,’ Says Owner

Protesters Seeking Gaza Cease-Fire Force Dems to Cancel Convention Events in Sacramento

Amid Netanyahu’s Ceasefire Refusal, Protests Emerge in Israel

World Health Organization Labels Gaza Hospital a ‘Death Zone’

Veterans Boulevard Opening Shows ‘Why We Need a New Measure C’

HBO’s John Oliver Discusses the Israel/Hamas War, Criticizes Congressman’s Comments

Taste The Spirit of a New Custom Bakery in Clovis